A Comprehensive Comparison of Premium High Efficiency Modulating Residential Furnaces: Trane, Carrier, Rheem, and York

June 19, 2025

A Comprehensive Comparison of Premium High Efficiency Modulating Residential Furnaces: Trane, Carrier, Rheem, and York 


When it comes to heating your home, choosing the right furnace is crucial. In recent years, modulating furnaces have gained popularity due to their energy efficiency and ability to maintain consistent temperatures. This article will provide a detailed comparison of four leading brands in the market: Trane, Carrier, Rheem, and York. We will explore their key performance characteristics, warranty, longevity, and overall value. 


Trane 


Trane is a well-known brand that offers a range of high-efficiency modulating furnaces. One of its top models is the Trane S9V2-VS, a two-stage variable speed gas furnace. It features an Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating of up to 97%, making it one of the most efficient models on the market. The S9V2-VS is equipped with Trane's Comfort-R technology, providing enhanced humidity control and consistent temperatures throughout your home. 


Key performance characteristics: 

  • AFUE rating up to 97% 
  • Comfort-R technology for superior temperature control 
  • Two-stage gas valve for efficient fuel consumption 

Trane's warranty is relatively competitive, offering a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger and a 10-year limited warranty on internal functional parts. When it comes to longevity, Trane has a reputation for durable and reliable products, so you can expect your furnace to last for many years with proper maintenance. 


Carrier 

Carrier is another reputable brand that offers a range of high-efficiency modulating furnaces. The Carrier Infinity 98 is a standout model, boasting an impressive AFUE rating of up to 98.5%. This model features Greenspeed intelligence, which allows it to adapt its output based on the specific needs of your home, ensuring optimal comfort and efficiency. 


Key performance characteristics: 

  • AFUE rating up to 98.5% 
  • Greenspeed intelligence for adaptive output 
  • Variable-speed blower motor for consistent temperature and improved air quality 

Carrier's warranty is quite comprehensive, offering a 10-year parts limited warranty and a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger. Like Trane, Carrier has a solid reputation for reliability and longevity, so you can expect your furnace to serve you well for many years. 


Rheem 

Rheem is a well-established brand that offers a variety of high-efficiency modulating furnaces. The Rheem Prestige R98V is a top-of-the-line model with an impressive AFUE rating of up to 98%. It features Rheem's EcoNet technology, which allows for easy control and monitoring of your furnace from anywhere using a smartphone or tablet. 


Key performance characteristics: 

  • AFUE rating up to 98% 
  • EcoNet technology for remote control and monitoring 
  • Modulating operation for precise temperature control 

Rheem's warranty is quite competitive, offering a 10-year limited warranty on parts and a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger. In terms of longevity, Rheem is known for manufacturing reliable and durable products, so you can expect your furnace to provide many years of efficient heating. 


York 

York is another popular brand offering high-efficiency modulating furnaces. The York Affinity Series YP9C is a noteworthy model, with an AFUE rating of up to 98%. This furnace features a modulating burner design, which allows it to adjust its heat output in small increments, ensuring precise temperature control and maximum efficiency. 


Key performance characteristics: 

  • AFUE rating up to 98% 
  • Modulating burner design for precise temperature control 
  • ClimaTrak Comfort System for customized performance based on regional climate 

York's warranty is quite comprehensive, offering a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger and a 10-year limited warranty on parts. When it comes to longevity, York has a reputation for manufacturing durable and long-lasting products. With proper maintenance, you can expect your York furnace to provide efficient heating for many years. 


Conclusion 

All four brands – Trane, Carrier, Rheem, and York – offer premium high-efficiency modulating residential furnaces that boast impressive performance and features. Each brand has its unique selling points, which cater to different consumer preferences. In terms of efficiency, all four models have similar AFUE ratings, with Carrier's Infinity 98 holding a slight edge at 98.5%. 


When it comes to warranty, all four brands offer competitive coverage, with lifetime limited warranties on the heat exchanger and 10-year limited warranties on parts. Longevity is also a common strength among these brands, as they all have a reputation for manufacturing reliable and durable products. 


In terms of value, each brand offers different advantages: 

  • Trane: Known for its Comfort-R technology, Trane's S9V2-VS provides superior temperature control and humidity management. 
  • Carrier: The Infinity 98 model boasts the highest AFUE rating and Greenspeed intelligence, offering adaptive output for optimal comfort and efficiency. 
  • Rheem: The Prestige R98V features EcoNet technology, allowing for easy control and monitoring of your furnace from anywhere using a smartphone or tablet. 
  • York: The Affinity Series YP9C has a modulating burner design and the ClimaTrak Comfort System, which tailors performance based on regional climate. 

Ultimately, the choice between these four premium high-efficiency modulating residential furnaces will depend on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. It is essential to consult with a qualified HVAC professional to ensure that you select the best furnace for your home. By doing so, you can enjoy the benefits of energy-efficient and consistent heating, creating a comfortable living environment for years to come. 



 



mini-split unit installation near me toledo ohio
June 19, 2025
A single zone mini-split system is an energy-efficient and versatile solution for heating and cooling individual rooms or spaces within your home. Mini-split systems consist of an indoor air handling unit and an outdoor condenser unit, connected by refrigerant lines. Installing a mini-split system can be a manageable DIY project for homeowners with some electrical and HVAC experience. In this article, we will guide you through the process of installing a single zone mini-split system.
ac maintenance company near me
June 19, 2025
If you've noticed a musty smell in your home, it can be frustrating and even embarrassing when you have guests over. Not only is it unpleasant, but it can also be a sign of a bigger problem such as mold or mildew growth. Here are some tips on how to get rid of that musty smell and keep your home smelling fresh and clean.
radiant heat installation service company near me toledo ohio
June 19, 2025
Radiant heat refers to a method of space heating that involves the direct transfer of heat from a warm surface to the objects and people in the room through infrared radiation. Unlike conventional heating systems, which primarily rely on circulating heated air, radiant heating works by directly warming the surfaces of a room. There are various types of radiant heating systems, including those that use electric resistance heating or those that circulate heated water through pipes (hydronic systems), commonly installed beneath floors or within walls.
tankless water heater installation near me toledo ohio
June 19, 2025
Water heaters are a fundamental component of modern living, providing hot water for cooking, cleaning, and bathing. The two most popular types of water heaters are tank and tankless systems. This article will compare tank and tankless water heaters, taking into account factors such as efficiency, size, and water usage, as well as their suitability for residential and commercial applications.
toledo geothermal heat installation company near me
June 19, 2025
The increasing demand for renewable and efficient energy sources has led to the rise of innovative heating and cooling solutions, such as geothermal heating and air source heat pumps. Homeowners and businesses are often faced with the challenge of choosing between these two systems. In this article, we will compare the features, advantages, and drawbacks of both systems to help you make an informed decision.
ac unit service company toldeo ohio
June 18, 2025
The heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) industry has grown exponentially in recent years, with advancements in technology offering homeowners increased comfort, better energy efficiency, and cost savings. One of the most sought-after technologies in this field is the high-efficiency split system residential heat pump, which has a Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) of 20 or higher. This article will compare the top 10 premium heat pump brands, discussing key performance characteristics, warranties, longevity, and overall value.
furnace replacement services toledo ohio
June 18, 2025
When it comes to heating your home, the decision can be as crucial and complex as choosing between a Mustang and a Corvette. Trane and Carrier are the Ford and Chevy of the HVAC world. They both deliver power, reliability, and a comfortable ride, but which one should you rev your engines for? Let's pit these two industry titans against each other in a straight-up drag race, looking at their pros and cons.
 boiler system repair company near me Toledo Ohio
June 18, 2025
A boiler radiant heating system is an efficient and comfortable way to heat your home. However, trapped air in the pipes can lead to cold spots, uneven temperatures, and reduced efficiency. Bleeding the air out of your system is essential for optimal performance and maintaining a comfortable indoor environment. This article will guide you through the process of bleeding air out of the pipes in your boiler radiant heating system.
air conditioner installation company Toledo Ohio
June 18, 2025
When it comes to air conditioning, there are two main types of systems to choose from: high velocity and low velocity. Both types of systems have their own unique advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to understand the differences between them before making a decision.
frozen ac repair toledo ohio
June 18, 2025
When the temperature starts rising outside, the last thing you want is for your AC unit to freeze up. Not only is it frustrating, but it can also lead to significant damages to your unit. If your air conditioner has frozen, you may be wondering how long it will take to defrost. Let's take a closer look at the defrosting process and how long it typically takes.
Show More

We're Listening | Get a free quote today!

Fry - Blog