As one of the best HVAC companies in Toledo, Ohio, our HVAC technicians have worked with some of the country's top heating and cooling brands and lines. For years, the two dominant companies in the HVAC space, especially for residential furnaces, have been Trane and Carrier. Both are great, and as fully trained and accredited technicians for both brands, the team at Fry is uniquely set up to provide an in-depth comparison of these two behemoths in the furnace industry.
Carrier
Carrier is a proud American company with over 100 years of experience in heating and cooling. Their founder, Willis Carrier, was the man who invented modern air conditioning back in 1902, and their current offerings provide clients of all budgets with a great option for their furnace needs. With a focus on technology and great builds, Carrier is an amazing option for those who are looking for a high-end, cost-effective furnace.
Carrier- The Smarter Brand
Carrier has really embraced technology in their furnaces. Whether you are looking for a connected furnace to a smart home system or want remote control over your HVAC system, Carrier has the features you have always wanted. Their tech, when paired with their energy efficiency and quiet operation, makes Carrier a popular choice for those looking for an amazing residential furnace.
Trane
With over 100 years of excellence, Trane Technologies has been in the residential furnace industry for generations, and its high-efficiency furnaces are among the best. Known to be at the cutting edge of innovation, Trane is constantly improving its offerings and provides clients with a wide variety of options for budget and high-end users. With its extreme durability and comprehensive warranty, investing in a Trane furnace is always a smart decision for homeowners.
Trane- The Durability Champion
Trane is known for its superior build quality and often outlasts the industry average lifespan when properly maintained by a professional HVAC company. As a repair partner, if we do need to swap out parts, they are often under warranty and are readily available through Trane's numerous suppliers.
The Comparison
So, now that we know what each brings to the table, let's compare Trane and Carrier in two main areas, technology and components.
Technology
Both Carrier and Trane offer advanced technology on their units. Carrier units feature several smart features. One of them is the Infinity System Control, a smart thermostat that lets you remotely monitor your furnace and can even be voice-controlled via home assistants like Alexa. Carrier also has Comfort Heat Technology, which allows the unit to manage heat cycles by running the furnace at a lower stage to keep a consistent indoor temperature, and ComfortFan Technology, which customizes the fan speed to optimize air movement. Finally, Greenspeed Intelligence is also available on some models and uses variable-speed features to match heating demand, which has been proven to reduce heating bills by up to 60%.
Trane, on the other hand, offers a smaller set of technology features and focuses on core durability. Their ComfortLink II Communicating Technology allows your furnace to learn and adapt to your needs and can pair with a host of other components, including smart speakers and AI assistants. The variable-speed system is controlled by Trane's Comfort-R Technology, which delivers a quiet fan during operation and superior air movement.
Advantage- Carrier
Components
Trane and Carrier furnaces both feature high-quality components built to last. Carrier offers variable-speed blowers on its higher models, but its base models are one- or two-stage. On the other hand, Trane offers a variety of options, including four-speed and variable-speed draft motors, backed by a strong warranty and proven to be true workhorses.
Advantage- Trane
What Brand to Choose
This really depends on your specific needs. The most important aspect is to work with a professional heating and cooling company to install the unit. In most cases, proper installation is more important for the unit's viability than the unit's brand. However, if you are looking for a final consideration, here is our expert opinion.
Choose Trane:
If you are looking for a furnace that will last a long time and be dependable, without the bells and whistles that come with other HVAC brands.
Choose Carrier: If you want a connected furnace that is efficient and quiet, with a host of advanced features and easy integration with your existing smart home system.
Luckily, if you are in Toledo, OH, or Ann Arbor, MI, then you have the perfect HVAC company for both Trane and Carrier furnaces. Here at Fry, we can help you find your ideal furnace that not only meets your needs but is the right size for your home.
